Breaking Down the Recruiting Brick Wall: Evaluating & Selecting Candidates

This article is the last in a three-part series looking at how your organization can improve its hiring processes. Just joining us? Read parts one and two to learn about creating your success profile and sourcing candidates for your positions.

In Post 2 in our series “Breaking Down the Recruiting Brick Wall: How to Build More Effective Hiring Practices,” we shared a few active ways to go beyond your standard job postings and effectively source and recruit the right candidates for your organization.

Now that you know how to identify the top candidates for your pipeline, how will you evaluate them properly in order to make the best hire possible?

To assess candidates, your organization may follow standard practices such as reviewing resumes to look for at least the minimum qualifications; bringing qualified candidates through an interview process; or conducting reference checks with candidates’ former employers.

Many organizations often believe using one or two of these practices will be enough to decide whether a candidate is the right fit. But, rather than relying on a face-to-face interview or a reference check, putting together all of these practices (and more) will better allow you to gain a truer picture of who a candidate really is and how they will fit in at your organization.

Today we’ll help you take your core candidate evaluation practices to the next level and show you how to combine interviews, reference checks and other assessment tools to increase your chances of making a great hire.

Combining Assessment Tools to Evaluate & Select Candidates

Remember Your Candidate Success Profile

Before you begin evaluating candidates, refer back to the Candidate Success Profile we discussed in Post 1 to know what to look for when reviewing resumes, what to address with interview questions, etc. Like with the other steps in your hiring process, using the Success Profile as the foundation for your assessment process will ensure you choose the candidate with the right hard and soft skills needed in order to succeed in the role.

Nail the Interview

How would you rate your interview process? How would candidates rate it? A strong and consistent interview strategy is critical in evaluating candidates. Here are a few things to consider when putting yours together.

The Interview Team

Who from your organization will interview candidates? Should candidates meet with everyone in the first round, or will interviewers meet with candidates at different stages of the process? And will the interviews be cross-functional, or will candidates only meet with members of the hiring department?

Decide on the size and scope of your interview team at the beginning of the process, and follow the same interview structure and schedule with each candidate you bring through the interviews.

Maintaining a consistent interview team makes it easier to ensure that everyone involved in this stage understands the needs of the role and the qualifications you are seeking in a candidate. Logistically, keeping your interview team consistent can also make scheduling interviews go more smoothly, which will help you move quickly with candidates and maintain search momentum.

The Interview Questions

Use your Success Profile to develop questions that address the key areas you’ve identified that a candidate will need to excel in this role. Consider assigning specific skillsets for individual interviewers to focus on based on their respective areas. For example, a member of your finance team could assess the candidate’s analytical competence while a human resources professional evaluates cultural fit. You should also make sure to keep questions open-ended.

Ultimately, you want to design questions that will prompt candidates to provide specific examples relating back to the Success Profile or allowing you to observe their skills in action. Below is an example of what we’re talking about.

How you word your interview questions is crucial in eliciting an answer that gives you a better picture of the candidate’s views and working styles. In the scenario above, the word “control” baits the candidates, enabling you to figure out if and how they are able to partner across functions within your organization.

Scenario-Based Work Examples

Another way to evaluate candidates’ fit during the interview process is to assign a project to complete prior to your in-person meeting with them. These scenario-based work examples allow you to assess hard and soft skills that may be challenging to evaluate with questions alone.

For example, if filling a marketing position, you could ask candidates to develop a go-to-market strategy for a new product launch to present at their in-person interview. An assignment like this can allow you to see not only how candidates think strategically and creatively but also their ability to present to a leadership team.

Remember that these assignments or projects should also be based on the Success Profile; if “strong presentation skills” are not a key area you outlined, developing a way to evaluate this attribute would be irrelevant to your interview process.

2 More Tools to Help You Determine Who the Candidate Is

Psychometric Assessments

Many of our clients use assessments such as DiSC, Personalysis, MBTI and StrengthsFinder as evaluation tools when selecting new team members.

These tools measure an array of individual attributes, including behavior & personality, skills & competencies, emotional intelligence, motivators and values. And they aren’t just used for recruiting and hiring; many assessment suites include tests that address individual development & team building, job analysis & benchmarking, performance management and more.

Psychometric assessments can be valuable to an organization’s development and people management strategies, but they are more effective when you invest in them across your organization; rather than using an assessment for a single hire, you should adopt it for all current and new employees in order to assess your organization as a whole and maintain consistency going forward.

You will also need a trained facilitator to administer the test and interpret the results. If you aren’t ready to commit internal resources yet, engage a consultant who specializes in one or more assessment tools to oversee this process.

At 180one, we are big fans of incorporating these types of tests into your overall assessment approach, but remember that these tools are just one piece of your entire evaluation process and should not be considered “hire or not hire” tests.

Reference Checks

Most organizations conduct reference checks during the hiring process, but do you know how to make the references you receive more effective in assessing a candidate? Here are a couple of tips to help you improve your reference checks.

Ask the candidate for the right references.
The quality and reliability of your reference checks rely first on where the references come from. Again, refer back to your Success Profile as a reminder for exactly what you are looking for and determine who you need to talk to in order to learn more about how a candidate satisfies those key areas.

Hiring for a leadership position? Conduct a “360 Review” by having candidates provide you someone they report to, someone who reports to them and someone who is a peer to them to serve as references.

Rather than the candidate selecting the references to check, you could also specifically ask to speak to a former boss at ABC Company; how the candidate responds to this request will also be very telling in evaluating their fit for your organization.

Ask the references the right questions.
Like with interview questions you ask a candidate, questions for reference checks require finessing in order to draw out responses that will be useful in evaluating the candidate.

Need to know in what areas a candidate may be weak? Rather than asking, “What is the candidate’s biggest weakness?” ask a reference, “How can we help develop the candidate?” for a more honest and authentic response.

Putting All of the Pieces Together

After collecting information about your candidates through various channels (resumes, interviews, assessments, references, etc.), how do you use that data to help you make a hiring decision?

A pragmatic approach to evaluate candidates consists of developing a simple ranking system to see how their skills and fit stack up.

Create a Candidate Assessment Scoring Matrix and rank every candidate using a numeric scale on how well they meet the criteria laid out in your Success Profile.

Make sure you have the evidence to support your rankings, though. If you didn’t assess a candidate’s leadership qualities in the interview, psychometric assessment or reference check, for instance, do not assume that they are a leader just because they have that title at their current organization.

Here is an example of a simple Scoring Matrix to give you an idea.

In the end, you want to feel confident in your hiring decision, and laying all of the information you gathered out in a Scoring Matrix will take the guesswork out of deciding whether a candidate is the best choice for the role and for your organization.

A Final Recap of the “Breaking Down the Recruiting Wall” Series

Much of the conversation about what makes a company successful today centers on one main thing: its people. But, while hiring and cultivating top talent is a priority for most organizations, many companies still lag behind when it comes to investing in sourcing, recruiting and assessing new candidates.

Over the past few months, 180one has provided insight into the marketplace and tips and strategies for how to up-level your company’s hiring practices so you can start “walking the walk” and investing more in your people.

After reading the “Breaking Down the Recruiting Brick Wall” series, you are now equipped to:

Build a strong foundation for your recruiting and hiring processes by knowing what you’re looking for when it comes to the ideal candidate for a position and your organization
Take a more active and creative approach to sourcing new talent by posting jobs more strategically, leveraging the media to promote your open positions, targeting specific candidates & companies and more
Redevelop your assessment process to more accurately evaluate and select the right candidates for your organization

Of course, elevating your entire hiring process may sound like a daunting task, but this is why the retained recruiting industry exists. For organizations that aren’t ready to overhaul their systems or don’t have all of the pieces in place yet internally, a retained search firm like 180one can provide the resources, experience and know-how to find the candidates who will succeed in the most challenging roles.

Ultimately, your people are your best asset, so there is no reason why you shouldn’t start investing in finding the right professionals for your organization today.

< Older Post

Newer Post >

The Cost of Hesitation: Why Delaying a Leadership Change Quietly Destroys Value

By Greg Togni • January 12, 2026

Few decisions carry more weight, or more emotional friction, than upgrading management. Whether in a private equity–backed business or a closely held private company, leaders know the decision matters. They also know it’s uncomfortable. Incumbent executives may have helped close the deal, built the business, or earned deep loyalty from employees and customers. In that context, waiting can feel prudent, even humane. Yet across ownership structures, cycles, and industries, the evidence points in one direction: delaying action on leadership misalignment quietly erodes value long before performance visibly breaks. What the Data Consistently Shows Research across management transitions paints a consistent picture. Roughly half of PE-backed companies replace the CEO within the first two years of ownership, with many changes occurring in the first year. Studies of executive transitions show failure rates between 30% and 40% in the first 18 months, most often driven not by incompetence but by misalignment- on mandate, pace, or priorities. The lesson is not that boards are impatient. It’s that leadership fit matters more than familiarity, and a misfit rarely corrects itself with time. The Most Expensive Period Is After Doubt Sets In By the time a board or ownership group agrees that a leadership upgrade may be needed, value erosion is often already underway. Growth initiatives slow. Decision-making becomes cautious. Reporting grows heavier as leaders explain results instead of driving them. High performers sense uncertainty and begin to disengage. In PE-backed environments, this dynamic plays out faster and with fewer buffers. But private companies experience the same slow bleed, just over a longer horizon. The “One More Quarter” Fallacy “Let’s give it one more quarter” is one of the most expensive sentences in governance. Boards and owners often justify delay by pointing to an initiative in flight, system implementation, or temporary market headwinds. But studies of executive performance show that trajectory matters more than absolute results. If clarity, momentum, and conviction are not improving, time rarely fixes the issue. A common pattern: leadership change is debated for several quarters. When a new executive finally steps in, they make decisive moves within 60 to 90 days, moves that had been discussed, analyzed, and deferred for a year. The opportunity cost of that delay is real, even if it never appears cleanly in the P&L. Missed Windows Are Permanent Losses The most dangerous cost of waiting is not short-term underperformance; it’s a missed opportunity. In PE-backed companies, similar windows appear around add-on acquisitions, operational transformations, or pricing resets. A capable but misaligned leader can miss those windows by moving too slowly or pulling the wrong levers. Once missed, those opportunities rarely reopen on the same terms. Loyalty Is Expensive, But So Is Delay Many delayed leadership changes stem from understandable loyalty: to founders, long-tenured executives, or leaders who were instrumental during diligence or early growth. But fiduciary responsibility ultimately outweighs emotional equity. The most effective boards separate gratitude for past contributions from clarity about future requirements. They also recognize that earlier action is usually kinder. Early transitions allow for controlled narratives, thoughtful role changes, and dignified exits. Late-stage changes tend to feel abrupt, personal, and destabilizing. A Simple Test for Owners and Boards One question cut through most debates: If we were hiring for this role today, knowing what we now know, would we make the same choice? If the answer isn’t an unambiguous yes, delay rarely improves the outcome. Another signal is how leadership discussions consume time. When meetings shift from strategy and growth to coaching, shielding, or compensating for leadership gaps, the decision has often already been made, just not acknowledged. Why Smart Owners Explore the Market Early High-performing PE firms, and increasingly, sophisticated private owners, often explore the executive market before a final decision is reached. This isn’t about undermining management; it’s about sharpening judgment. Seeing the caliber of available talent reframes the question from “Can this work?” to “Is this the best we can do?” In many cases, an external perspective provides clarity faster than another quarter of internal debate. Timing is Everything Upgrading management is never easy. But the evidence, data, deals, and lived experience are clear: indecision is rarely neutral. The organizations that consistently outperform aren’t the ones that change leaders most often. They’re the ones who change them on time. And in a world of compressed timelines, competitive markets, and rising expectations, timing isn’t just a leadership issue; it’s a value creation issue.

New Opportunity: General Counsel

By Effie Zimmerman • January 5, 2026

General Counsel ABOUT THE COMPANY A-dec is the premium leader in the dental equipment industry, designing and manufacturing products that span dental chairs, lights, handpieces, furniture, air management, infection control, and delivery systems found in dental offices and operatories. With over 1300 employees and headquartered in Newberg, Oregon, A-dec’s familial culture and values have been attributed to their commitment to the Newberg community and its employees through various investments and programs. ABOUT THE POSITION The General Counsel (GC) will manage legal matters for the organization and affiliated entities, including all litigation defense coordination, intellectual property, business development, contracting, unfair trade practices, anti-trust, corporate governance, and the coordination of legal matters managed by outside counsel. GC will provide legal advice to management, provide counsel on negotiating corporate transactions, and prepare related documentation. Provide strong leadership, guidance, and pragmatic business acumen, recognizing the business consequences of legal advice. GC is a strategic and innovative thinker who can develop and articulate a clear understanding of the company’s strategy from all perspectives and find creative solutions to complex legal problems with a strong ability to balance legal and business risk. DUTIES & RESPONSIBILITIES Corporate Governance & Strategy Serve as a trusted legal advisor to the executive leadership team on corporate governance and risk management. Oversee corporate governance matters, including board support, entity management, and compliance with applicable corporate laws. Support business development, joint ventures, and other strategic transactions from due diligence through integration. Board meeting preparation and serves as acting Secretary in Board of Directors’ meetings and prepares all necessary Board and Shareholder documents. Regulatory & Compliance Partner with corporate regulatory leaders to ensure compliance with U.S. and international laws and regulations applicable to medical/dental devices, manufacturing, quality systems, and global distribution. Interface with corporate regulatory leaders to manage regulatory risk and ensure compliance. Develop, implement, and maintain company-wide compliance policies and training programs. Commercial & Contract Management Draft, review, and negotiate a wide range of commercial agreements, including supplier, distributor, licensing, manufacturing, and customer contracts. Support global sales and supply chain operations with practical, business-focused legal guidance. Establish contract standards and processes to improve efficiency and risk management. Intellectual Property Oversee protection, management, and enforcement of the company’s intellectual property portfolio, including patents, trademarks, and trade secrets. Work with internal teams and external counsel on IP strategy aligned with product development and global expansion. Litigation & Risk Management Manage all litigation, disputes, and claims, including product liability and commercial matters. Select and manage outside counsel, controlling costs and ensuring high-quality outcomes. Oversee risk mitigation strategies. Legal Operations Build and lead the legal function, including internal staff and external legal resources. Develop budgets, manage legal spend, and improve legal operations and processes. Foster a culture of ethics, compliance, and sound risk judgment across the organization. MINIMUM QUALIFICATIONS Knowledge, Skills and Abilities Strong business acumen with the ability to balance legal risk and commercial objectives. Deep understanding of regulatory, compliance, and quality requirements in a manufacturing environment. Excellent negotiation, communication, and leadership skills. Practical, solutions-oriented mindset with high ethical standards. Ability to work collaboratively with business clients and proactively become involved in business initiatives. Ability to interact effectively with associates at all levels in all businesses across North America and in countries where A-dec has a presence. Ability to interface and negotiate with legal representatives at dealers and suppliers. Ability to communicate clearly, concisely, and effectively. Good listening skills. Skilled at working independently and leading critical matters to conclusion with little supervision, while coordinating with other attorneys and stakeholders. Demonstrated ability to quickly establish trust and rapport within A-dec. Strong leadership skills to manage projects and influence decisions, with the ability to be persuasive in reinforcing the best interests of the company. Understands business implications of decisions. Strong analytical, organizational, and time management skills. Travel, including internationally as needed, to perform the duties of the job. Expert legal document drafting and research skills. Education and Experience Requires Juris Doctor (JD) from an accredited law school. Must be a member of the bar in good standing; admission to the Oregon State Bar preferred. 10+ years of legal experience in a relevant law firm or corporate setting. Experience as an Associate, Assistant, or General Counsel is preferred. Experience in medical devices, pharmaceuticals, or other healthcare-related experience is desirable. Experience in a manufacturing business is preferred. Experience in a global business with international distribution is preferred. Interested in Learning More? 180one has been retained by A-dec to manage this search. If interested in learning more about the opportunity, please contact Lisa Heffernan / 971.256.3076/ lisa@180one.com .

New Opportunity: Chief Financial Officer

By Effie Zimmerman • December 23, 2025

Chief Financial Officer ABOUT THE COMPANY Superior Duct Fabrication is a market-leading fabricator of highly technical commercial ducting and specialty HVAC products, serving mission-critical end markets such as data centers, semiconductor manufacturing, healthcare, higher education, and industrial facilities. Founded in 2002 and headquartered in Pomona, CA, Superior operates out of five strategic manufacturing sites across the Western U.S. and Ohio, with a deeply experienced union workforce, vertically integrated operations, and a reputation for quality, speed, and reliability. In 2025, Seattle-based private equity firm Pike Street Capital made a platform investment in Superior to accelerate growth through geographic expansion, product innovation, and targeted acquisitions. With a strong leadership team, trusted customer relationships, and increasing demand for sophisticated air handling solutions, Superior is positioned for rapid, scalable growth. THE ROLE Superior is seeking an experienced and results-driven Chief Financial Officer (CFO) to lead the financial strategy and execution of its private equity-backed, high-growth business. The CFO will play a critical role in enabling both organic and acquisitive growth, optimizing operations, and driving value creation in partnership with the CEO, President, and private equity sponsor. This is a hands-on executive leadership role ideal for a proven financial leader with deep manufacturing expertise and a track record of operating in dynamic, performance-driven environments. RESPONSIBILITIES Executive & Strategic Leadership Serve as a strategic partner to the CEO and executive team, actively contributing to policy, direction, and long-term planning. Help define and execute the company’s growth strategy in alignment with operational, financial, and market objectives. Drive a high-performance culture through accountability, transparency, and collaboration. Lead by example, setting the tone and culture across the organization. Operate as a player/coach—comfortable building models, developing presentations, and engaging directly in critical business issues. Attract, develop, and retain top-tier financial and operational talent. Lead major business initiatives and projects (e.g., productivity improvement, pricing strategies) with measurable results. Shoulder broad business leadership responsibility, beyond traditional finance functions. Financial Planning & Analysis (FP&A) Own the development and ongoing refinement of annual budgets, monthly forecasts, and long-term financial planning. Track and maintain key performance indicators (KPIs) to measure performance against strategic goals. Conduct hands-on analysis of financial performance, with actionable insights to achieve growth and EBITDA targets. Lead investment analysis and decision support—including customer pricing models and full business case development. Demonstrated expertise in labor cost management and margin improvement strategies. Bring experience across multiple ERP platforms; ERP selection and implementation experience is highly preferred. Accounting & Financial Operations Oversee all accounting and finance functions, ensuring accuracy, integrity, and timeliness of financial information. Prepare and deliver comprehensive financial reporting packages, including monthly P&L, balance sheet, cash flow, and covenant compliance. Ensure all financial statements are prepared in accordance with GAAP and meet internal and external stakeholder requirements. Lead all month-end close activities, including general ledger, balance sheet reconciliations, and overhead allocation. Enhance and scale accounting processes, systems, and internal controls to support company growth. Coordinate the annual audit process, ensuring unqualified audit results. Lead the preparation and management of company-wide budgets, including revenue and capital expenditure planning. Treasury & Working Capital Management Lead cash flow forecasting, management, and decision-making around weekly cash disbursements. Improve the full cash cycle—credit policy, collections, inventory, and payables management. Manage lender relationships and covenant compliance. Use forward-looking cash flow analysis to guide capital structure decisions and working capital strategy. M&A & Private Equity Engagement Collaborate with the leadership team and private equity sponsors on M&A add-on strategies and roll-up execution. Experience or understanding of value creation planning, reporting, and board-level communication. QUALIFICATIONS Bachelor’s degree in Finance, Accounting, Business Administration, or a related discipline; CPA and MBA strongly preferred. Extensive experience in senior financial leadership roles, ideally within a private equity-backed or high-growth manufacturing environment. Deep understanding of financial and operational disciplines, including P&L ownership, balance sheet management, cash flow optimization, and capital allocation. Demonstrated experience in corporate governance, risk management, and regulatory compliance. Proven ability to lead complex negotiations related to financing, vendor agreements, M&A, and commercial terms. Expertise in budgeting, forecasting, financial modeling, and working capital management; prior public accounting experience is a plus. Strong business acumen with the ability to quickly assess new challenges and make sound, data-driven decisions in a dynamic environment. Natural leadership presence with the ability to build trust and credibility across all levels of an organization and with external stakeholders. Resilient under pressure with a disciplined approach to prioritization, execution, and delegation. Exceptional communication skills—both written and verbal—with the ability to clearly articulate financial concepts to non-financial stakeholders. Committed to service excellence, with strong interpersonal skills and a collaborative leadership style. High attention to detail and precision, balanced with the ability to think strategically and see the broader business context. Interested in Learning More? 180one has been retained by Superior Duct Fabrication to manage this search. If interested in learning more about the opportunity, please contact Tom Haley /503.334.1350/ tom@180one.com .