Rethinking the Org Chart: Why Successful Companies Avoid Overloading Managers

In today’s business climate, reorganizations have become the norm rather than the exception. Companies shift structure to respond to market changes, streamline costs, adopt new technologies, or realign with strategy. But while the headlines focus on job cuts or new leadership, one critical factor often overlooked in the success or failure of a reorganization is managerial span of control: the number of direct reports assigned to each manager.


When companies get this wrong, they risk derailing even the best-planned structural change. When they get it right, the results include faster decision-making, improved employee engagement, and better execution of strategic goals.

So how do the most successful companies handle this delicate balance during a reorg?


The Pitfalls of Overloading Managers


The pressure to do more with less can tempt organizations to increase the number of employees reporting directly to each manager. After all, fewer managers mean lower salary overhead, less bureaucracy, and theoretically, a leaner, faster organization.


But research consistently shows that increasing a manager’s span of control beyond a certain point leads to declining effectiveness, both for the manager and their team.


According to a comprehensive study by Bain & Company, companies with top-quartile performance in productivity and employee engagement tend to cap manager spans at no more than 7 to 10 direct reports, depending on the complexity of the work and the level of autonomy of the team.


Beyond this range, several problems begin to surface:

  • Decreased coaching and development time: With too many direct reports, managers struggle to provide regular feedback or support individual growth.
  • Slower decision-making: Managers become bottlenecks as more team members wait for approvals or guidance.
  • Increased burnout: Overloaded managers report higher levels of stress, disengagement, and turnover.
  • Reduced innovation: Less time for strategic thinking means less opportunity to solve problems creatively or improve team performance.


Harvard Business Review echoes this concern, noting that “as spans widen, the average quality of management and leadership drops,” especially in knowledge-driven or high-complexity work environments.


Span of Control: One Size Doesn’t Fit All


So what’s the right number? The answer depends on context, and smart companies know that not all roles, teams, or business units require the same structure.


Key variables include:

  • Task complexity: Teams doing routine, repeatable work (like call centers or transactional processing) can operate effectively with spans as wide as 15-20 direct reports. In contrast, research and development teams often require narrower spans due to higher collaboration and oversight needs.
  • Employee experience: Highly experienced, autonomous employees require less hands-on supervision, allowing for broader spans.
  • Manager capability: Not all managers are equally equipped to handle large teams. Leadership training, experience, and support systems (like team leads or AI tools) can influence optimal span.
  • Organizational culture: Companies with strong cultures of self-management and clear accountability structures may tolerate wider spans without performance drops.


A 2023 McKinsey report emphasizes this variability, stating, “Leading companies tailor spans of control by role and level, not by arbitrary benchmarks.”


Case in Point: Reorg Success Stories


Let’s look at a few organizations that have successfully navigated reorgs by paying close attention to managerial spans:


1.  Microsoft

During Satya Nadella’s early tenure as CEO, Microsoft underwent a major organizational overhaul to break down silos and improve collaboration. A key part of the strategy was flattening the org, but not indiscriminately. Nadella emphasized “clarity of purpose” and invested heavily in leadership development to ensure managers were ready to handle broader spans only where appropriate.

The result? Productivity rose, engagement improved, and innovation accelerated across product teams.


2. Procter & Gamble (P&G)

P&G restructured in the early 2010s to reduce costs and improve agility. Rather than simply cutting layers, the company also reassessed manager-to-employee ratios by function. In areas like finance, where standard processes prevail, spans increased. In innovation and marketing roles, they were kept tight to preserve creativity and oversight. The tailored approach helped P&G maintain performance through a major shift.


3. Spotify

Famous for its “squad” model, Spotify empowers small autonomous teams with clear leadership support. Managers, often called Chapter Leads, have limited spans to ensure close mentorship and skill development within specific technical domains. This model has supported Spotify’s growth while preserving agility and innovation.


Practical Guidance for Leaders Planning a Reorg


If your company is considering, or currently navigating, a reorganization, here are five evidence-based principles to keep in mind:


1. Start with the work, not the structure

Begin by analyzing the actual tasks teams are responsible for. How complex is the work? How interdependent are the roles? What level of oversight is needed? Design the structure around the needs of the work, not arbitrary span targets.


2. Avoid flattening without a function

Flattening layers can reduce costs, but it can also create chaos if not executed thoughtfully. Ensure that wider spans are matched with the right capabilities, tools, and cultural support.


3. Invest in manager readiness

If you do decide to widen spans, ensure your managers are trained in time management, delegation, coaching, and the use of technology. Even experienced managers can falter without support.


4. Use data to monitor and adjust

Keep track of KPIs like employee engagement, turnover, decision speed, and manager satisfaction post-reorg. These can provide early warning signs if spans are too wide or teams are struggling.


5. Communicate clearly and consistently

Structural changes can breed uncertainty. Communicate not just what is changing, but why, and how it will improve the experience for both managers and their teams.


Structure Should Enable Strategy


A reorganization is not just a reshuffling of boxes on an org chart, it’s an opportunity to realign your workforce with your business goals. But even the most visionary strategy will falter if leaders are overwhelmed, disengaged, or unsupported.


As the research shows, successful reorgs pay close attention to the human factor. Avoiding overly wide spans of control is not about bureaucracy; it’s about enabling leaders to lead.


By Effie Zimmerman • October 26, 2026
Director of Global Supply Planning & Logistics ABOUT THE COMPANY A-dec is the premium leader in the dental equipment industry, designing and manufacturing products that span dental chairs, lights, handpieces, furniture, air management, infection control, and delivery systems found in dental offices and operatories. With over 1300 employees and headquartered in Newberg, Oregon, A-dec’s familial culture and values have been attributed to their commitment to the Newberg community and its employees through various investments and programs. ABOUT THE POSITION Reporting directly to the SVP Manufacturing & Supply Chain, the Director, Global Supply Planning & Logistics leads A-dec’s planning and fulfillment organization – supply planning, production planning, inventory control; the Sales, Inventory & Operations Planning (SIOP) process, trade and transportation, and warehousing and shipping. The Director owns the SIOP process and is accountable for material availability, on-time delivery, inventory, and working-capital performance. The Director will learn A-dec’s current practices and processes while looking for opportunities to transform our supply and inventory planning into a robust, customer-centric, data-driven supply and inventory planning capability. This role will lead the planning operating model, introduce modern tools and analytics (including AI), find more efficient processes, and continually invest in and build our logistics and planning talent. DUTIES & RESPONSIBILITIES Owns and runs the SIOP process, balancing demand and supply across the enterprise. Leads supply planning, production planning, and inventory control to meet customer demand while achieving working-capital targets. Oversees trade and transportation, warehousing, and shipping to ensure accurate, on-time delivery of materials and finished goods. Leads the transformation of planning from a master-planner-driven model to a robust, data-driven supply and inventory planning capability. Owns and improves the planning operating model — process, roles, standard work, and governance. Identifies and deploys planning tools, systems, and analytics, including AI, to advance planning decision-making, and builds the data quality required to use them. Drives on-time delivery, inventory turns, forecast and plan accuracy, and service-level performance. Leads and develops the planning and logistics organization, building a high-functioning team and developing future leaders. Partners with the Director, Global Sourcing & Contract Manufacturing through the SIOP process and the supplier-to-plan handoff, and with Manufacturing, Finance, and Sales & Marketing to support growth, financial, and quality objectives. Defines, monitors, and reports planning and logistics key performance indicators, using scorecards to manage performance. Leads inventory and excess-and-obsolescence management and supply continuity within planning and logistics. Develops and manages the planning and logistics budget. Promotes and fosters a culture that results in a safe working environment, sponsoring EHS initiatives. QUALIFICATIONS  Knowledge, Skills and Abilities Excellent presentation, communication, and customer skills. Proven leadership skills and effective problem-solving skills. Ability to influence up, down, and across the organization. Strong change-leadership skills with the ability to design operating models and build organizational capability. Education and Experience Bachelor’s degree in supply chain, engineering, business management, operations or similar focus. At least ten years of increasing responsibility in supply chain planning functions. At least five years of people leadership experience. Demonstrated experience owning the SIOP/S&OP process and driving on-time delivery, inventory, and working capital performance. Proven experience leading a planning transformation – moving from manual or master-planner approaches to systemic, data-driven planning. Experience implementing planning systems, tools, and analytics; experience with AI or advanced analytics preferred. Experience leading logistics operations (trade and transportation, warehousing, and shipping) at scale is preferred. Experience leading and developing multi-functional teams and future leaders. Interested in Learning More? 180one has been retained by A-dec to manage this search. If interested in learning more about the opportunity, please contact Nicole Brady at 503-699-0184 or via email at nicole@180one.com .
By Effie Zimmerman • October 20, 2026
Chief Information Officer ABOUT THE COMPANY With roots dating back to 1938, The Papé Group is the West’s leading supplier of capital equipment solutions. Today, Papé operate across nine states with over 4,000 team members, proudly representing premier brands including John Deere, Kenworth, Hyster, Ditch Witch, and more. What sets Papé apart is its commitment to long-term relationships, both with customers and employees. As a fourth-generation, family-led business, Papé believes in the value of a handshake, the importance of service, and the impact of leadership that stays close to the work. ABOUT THE POSITION The Chief Information Officer (CIO) provides leadership and management of the information technology function for the company. The CIO is responsible for providing leadership and development to the corporate technology team, including software development, infrastructure, support, web development, database administration, and applications development. The CIO will partner with company-wide business leaders to align their business needs as well as corporate initiatives with cost-effective technology strategies and solutions to achieve those goals as the company continues to grow and evolve. Examples include the company’s One Customer | One Papé initiative that is designed to strengthen the relationship between customers and the company through a variety of mediums, with a heavy emphasis on leveraging technology. The CIO will be a proven technology and business leader and possess broad-based progressive IT leadership experience. The role requires sophisticated management skills in IT planning, organizational design and development, and process thinking. Papé has completed 25+ acquisitions over the past 8 years, with each acquisition being fully integrated into Papé’s technology infrastructure and systems on day one. Essential Duties and Responsibilities Team Management and Development Lead, train, develop, and coach a high-performance information technology team; identifying appropriate staffing needs, skill sets, or alternative outsourcing. Align IT's organizational structure and initiatives with company-wide requirements for technology solutions, information needs and security requirements. Responsible for optimizing the IT demands and the supply capacity of the teams to prioritize the assignment of resources. Set objectives and strategies for the IT team. Strategic and Business Planning Develop and execute short-, mid-, and long-term strategic technology and system roadmaps that translate business requirements into projects, goals, objectives, and deliverables with the business partners and end-user experience in mind. Establish the objectives for operations, maintenance, and enhancement of the IT systems and a plan for continuous improvement of the service levels. Help define IT infrastructure strategy, architecture, and processes. Drive a coordinated ERP approach across all of Papé’s operating companies to ensure the success and integrity of the overall design and integrations with other technologies. Technology and Infrastructure Full operational management responsibility for information and telecommunication technology functions and services; ensures appropriate implementation and support for business systems by managing and coordinating applications development/maintenance, data processing, data center infrastructure, local/wide area network administration, office automation, and technical support activities. Responsible for building and optimizing the evolving needs of system-level architectural capabilities to support the data and integration strategies. Evaluate effectiveness, efficiency, and costs of existing technology and systems, research new or alternative solutions, and make recommendations to senior management as appropriate. Maintain working knowledge of new and evolving technologies and systems for possible application to development or future organization needs. Identify emerging issues in technology and digital processes and develop strategies to implement value-added technology, collaborating with functional areas of the business impacted. Participate in the evaluation of new tools, platforms and technologies and articulate the business case for investments. Provide architecture leadership around technology interfaces with systems outside of the ERP, including those that reside with the OEMs, and the company’s CRM. Ensure that the organization continues to stay current with the latest technology security applications and tools to guard against cyber threats. Project Management Develop and manage project plans in collaboration with functional business leaders to ensure proper resource utilization, expense management, and timely completion. Leads large IT projects, including the design and deployment of new IT systems and services. Develop and manage the annual information technology department budget; includes project planning, expense management, and external resource utilization. Prioritize, assign, and manage a portfolio of technology projects in support of business goals; ensure delivery of projects within time and cost limitations. Partner with other functional leaders on implementation and company-wide adoption of new technology and/or processes through effective change management. External Relationships Provide expertise and leadership in the selection and management of vendors to provide low-cost, high-efficiency solutions. Represent Papé at industry conferences and be an active member with the OEMs to help influence technology outcomes. Business Partnering Engage, build, and partner with executive leaders and key stakeholders to ensure alignment with current and long-term business objectives. Work closely with cross-functional leaders to identify technology business needs, develop collaborative solutions and execution plans in alignment with the business strategy. Be obsessed with delivering results, insist on high standards, possess a knack for thinking strategically and “finding a way”, and an external awareness and curiosity to innovate and disrupt within the capital equipment market. Participate, as a member of the business leadership team, in strategic planning activities by providing systemic and technological solutions where business opportunities or challenges are identified. Ensure a business intelligence structure and tools are in place to deliver appropriate information to decision makers. Qualifications Bachelor’s degree in information systems, business, or equivalent analytical and strategic management capabilities acquired through on-the-job experience and training. 10+ years of progressive leadership experience with 5+ years in a senior leadership position managing a similar scope and size technology team. Proven success leading IT, preferably in a complex, multi-location, multi-business organization, preferably involving equipment dealerships, distribution, or similar operationally intensive businesses. Experience integrating and progressively modernizing custom legacy applications alongside cloud, SaaS, and emerging AI technologies. Ability to analyze business needs and recommend and implement appropriate solutions. Ability to develop and collect key performance indicators to measure performance. Experience managing a wide variety and scope of information technology projects that successfully achieve time, cost, and operational expectations. Comprehensive knowledge of IS technology architecture, software, ERP experience, cloud computing, mobile computing, IT security, and company-wide training. Experienced in leading teams of IT professionals and staff across multiple technical disciplines Ability to communicate vision, motivate workforce, create effective teams, and build strong peer relationships. Ability to prioritize and manage multiple ongoing projects and responsibilities to meet business technology needs. Experience in developing and supporting customer-facing business systems and/or implementing related digital transformation initiatives. Strong ability to collaborate functionally with other management and leadership team members. An effective communicator who clearly and concisely conveys information and ideas to all levels of the organization and uses your influencing skills to advance shared interests and business goals. Innovative problem solver with critical thinking skills and strong analytical abilities. Experience with system integration and change management. Interested in Learning More? 180one is assisting The Papé Group in this search. If interested in learning more about the opportunity, please contact Tom Haley/ 503.334.1350/ tom@180one.com .
By Effie Zimmerman • October 13, 2026
Chief Financial Officer ABOUT THE COMPANY Kenworth Sales Company is a multi-generation, family-owned commercial truck dealership founded in 1945 and headquartered in West Valley City, Utah. With more than 1,400 employees across 38 locations, the company provides comprehensive truck sales, parts, service, leasing, rental, and financing solutions throughout the Intermountain West and Mid-Atlantic regions. Recognized as Kenworth Dealer of the Year in both 2020 and 2025, Kenworth Sales Company has built its reputation on quality products, superior service, and a long-standing commitment to its customers and communities. ABOUT THE POSITION Reporting directly to the President, the Chief Financial Officer provides strategic leadership and oversight across accounting, financial reporting, compliance, information technology, security and risk management, finance, and treasury. As a key member of the senior leadership team, the CFO plays an integral role in shaping the Company’s business strategy, financial direction, capital planning, and overall operations. Essential Duties and Responsibilities SENIOR MANAGEMENT Actively participate as a member of senior management to execute the company’s business strategy. Establish and maintain effective working relationships with the dealer principal, board of directors, family business council, president, COO’s, and senior management. Ensure compliance with the company’s vision, mission, and values. Coordinate the preparation of annual business plans for all departments, including forecasts for future business growth, general economic, industry, and financial conditions. Analyze financial operations and identify areas of improvement. Develop innovative and effective financing strategies to support Company operations and growth. Evaluate growth opportunities including valuation analysis, due diligence, financing, risk assessment, purchase agreement support, and post-acquisition integration planning. Develop and foster productive relationships with outside tax, legal, accounting, banking, insurance, and investment advisors as appropriate to support succession planning for ownership and management. FINANCIAL REPORTING Supervise the company’s accounting and financial reporting systems. Ensure financial statements fully and accurately represent the financial position of Company operations and comply with GAAP standards. Design, maintain, and enforce appropriate internal controls, approval authorities, segregation of duties, financial policies, and fraud prevention processes to safeguard Company assets and ensure the integrity of financial reporting and business practices. Ensure reporting compliance with government authorities and regulators, franchisors, and funding institutions. Engage and coordinate all audit functions as directed by the board of directors. Coordinate and supervise internal audits for compliance with Corporate financial standards and related Company policies and procedures. Develop and maintain financial dashboards, key performance indicators, variance analyses, and management reporting tools that provide Management timely insight into financial performance, profitability, liquidity, departmental results, and emerging business trends. RISK MANAGEMENT Supervise the company's risk oversight, including the identification, management, and remediation of physical, virtual, reputational, financial, strategic, and operational risks inherent in all Company operations. Engage and effectively manage physical damage, liability, and business operations insurance coverage, loss prevention, cybersecurity, etc. CASH MANAGEMENT Supervise the company's cash flow. Develop and review pro forma financial and cash flow forecasts to ensure adequate money supply for Company operations. Oversee customer account services, including the receivables process. Develop and maintain strong banking and lender relationships including credit facilities, borrowing capacity, debt obligations, lender reporting, covenant compliance, and other treasury activities. Administer the company's financial obligations, ensuring compliance with contract terms including accounts payable and payment schedules. INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY Supervise the company’s information technology (IT) program, including cybersecurity oversight, systems reliability, data protection, software and vendor management, disaster recovery planning, business continuity support, and technology initiatives. QUALIFICATIONS Bachelor’s degree in accounting, finance, business, or related field required; MBA and/or CPA preferred. Minimum of 10 years of progressively responsible experience in senior financial, accounting, or audit roles, with experience operating at a leadership level. Strong knowledge of GAAP, financial reporting, corporate compliance, financial analysis, acquisitions, and negotiations. Experience with business operations, information technology, and/or the heavy-truck or commercial vehicle industry preferred. Demonstrated ability to lead, develop, and retain high-performing teams while improving organizational effectiveness. Excellent communication, interpersonal, organizational, time-management, and decision-making skills. Ability to analyze complex business issues, develop sound financial and business-case recommendations, and communicate them effectively to senior leadership. Ability to work independently, manage multiple priorities, and operate effectively in a fast-paced, changing business environment. Willingness and ability to travel as needed for business purposes. Interested in Learning More? 180one has been retained by Kenworth Sales Company to manage this search. If interested in learning more about the opportunity, please contact Lisa Heffernan / 971.256.3076/ lisa@180one.com .
More Posts