The CFO Shortage - A look at CFO Labor Market Trends


Looking at Google data, we see that between August and October 2022 there has been a significant uptick in searches for the terms “CFO” and “chief financial officer”—50% and 22% respectively. But even though Googling CFO is the simplest way to see these trends, it’s not the only confirmation that there is increasing demand for CFO candidates.


That rising demand is for a particular kind of CFO. Let’s call it the modern CFO. Let’s look at the current landscape as it has evolved along with businesses over the last couple of decades.


From Accounting to Financial Analysis and Planning – How the CFO role Evolves


Consider your basic business that has a product or service to sell. There is an initial investment to create your product. Revenue begins to flow. The business has someone on staff who has the accounting skills to keep track of revenues, expenses, and pay the taxes. This person may be called the controller, or maybe even the CFO. Over time, as the company grows, it begins to invest its profits in order to increase the business’s capacity, enter new markets, or increase the customer base. Instead of just tracking revenue and expenses, the CFO value to the company begins to shift from recording historical data to focus on driving long term performance of the company and how best to leverage its resources to accomplish the intended results.


The individual who started out as the controller is now expected to provide some financial analysis on a variety of business issues. What is the company’s breakeven point? What are the margins per customer or product? To increase capacity, should we increase the labor pool, invest in new equipment, or outsource? What is our return on this investment?  Should we finance our expanded capacity with operating cash flow, debt or raise through equity?


This is the point in the life of the business where the accounting and finance function begins to evolve from record keeping (historical) to helping the business make decisions with a financial approach (future-focused). In many instances, the individual in the controller role may not have the skills needed to provide this type of value.


Where Does the Modern CFO Exist?


Most large privately held or publicly traded companies have historically been a great training ground for modern CFOs. The accounting and finance functions not only ensure the accuracy of the financial statements, but they also work with other functional areas to help them manage financial results, as well as understanding the financial drivers of the business. This exists as these organizations require another level of financial sophistication in order to attract outside investors, board members, and maintain compliance as a public company. Most accounting and finance individuals who are trained in this world learn the best practices of their craft here.


What Does the Modern CFO Offer?



The modern CFO who drives business success is expected to bring the following to the table:

  • Economic approach to decision making – This is different from an accounting approach. It includes thinking about where to acquire more capital, whether to make investments etc.
  • Participation as an executive leader – While they might be officially in charge of the finance function, they now need to share their overall business acumen with the company to influence other decisions that are perhaps outside of their scope of responsibility. In many organizations, the CFO will even interact with customers in contract review/negotiation, but also for customer retention.
  • Ability to provide business partnering – These internal partnerships reflect the leadership of the modern CFO. The CFO and their team, partners with manufacturing, sales, marketing, and others to help them understand the decisions they make from an economic perspective, and how analysis and projections inform the interdependent web among all of the functional areas within a company.
  • Team management and development – The CFO’s team is on the front lines of business every day, having an impact on all functions. The CFO wants a team of financially savvy people who also have the emotional intelligence to help them partner and engage with other teams. The litmus test for a good financial team is whether they are being invited to meetings in other areas of the business, or if they have to invite themselves.


Supply and Demand – CFOs Who Drive Business Success to the Next Level


The demand for modern CFOs continues to increase based on a few critical drivers, while the supply isn’t keeping pace.


An increase in demand is being created by private equity firms acquiring companies who are for the first time accepting institutional investment. When this occurs, these companies typically need to adopt a new governance structure with a formal board, and since their new investors are financially astute – they normally desire the modern CFO to ensure both accurate financial reporting, and this modern CFO to help drive financial performance. A good portion of the companies that the PE firms acquire under this scenario don’t already have a modern CFO in the seat, resulting in the need to recruit an outsider.


In addition, medium sized family owned and/or founder led companies are increasingly adopting financial and governance best practices that were once only employed by public or PE backed companies. These shifts normally require a modern CFO which in turn is driving more demand for them.


Their pull on the dwindling supply affects the rise in demand and the subsequent shortage we are seeing. This article in the Association of Accountants and Financial Professionals in Business dives into the increased expectations for company CFOs.


The good news is that many financial officers currently working in high-stakes public companies want to take the skills they’ve learned over time and apply them in a business where the intense risk of projection-failure and the massive stress of issuing quarterly earnings won’t shorten their lifespans.


The bad news is that at this point that supply is dwindling and there are fewer truly experienced modern CFOs to meet the continually rising demand for their services.


CFO Recruiters – The Search for Your Next CFO


It is possible to recruit the modern CFO down from the heights to a company that wants to be more competitive, financially strategic, and continue to grow. Many CEOs are unsure of how to determine what CFO skills are needed in their company, let alone how to evaluate CFO candidates. If you have been searching for the CFO to move your business forward and are finding it tough to find the right person for the job, you are not alone. This is where an executive search firm with the right expertise can help a company not only align the company needs with the skills needed in the role, but also how to effectively run recruitment for this critical search.


This search is perhaps the most challenging there is, especially these days. Bringing in the expert on this will free you up to fill your countless other roles and focus on your endless list of important leadership tasks. Ending up with the right CFO will yield such growth that your search will have paid for itself in no time.


Check out our experience helping great companies hire modern financial leaders here!

29 Feb, 2024
Each year, 180one presents the Year in Review, sharing our insights into the overall executive talent market and recapping the work we performed on behalf of our clients throughout the year. To explore what we saw in years’ past, check out the Year in Review section of The Water Cooler.
By Christine Kennedy 12 Feb, 2024
 Business Manager About Us For over 55 years Shelter Products has supplied lumber, plywood, and related building materials to large, wood framed construction projects. Our sales are supported by staff headquartered in key metropolitan areas throughout the U.S. We specialize in mill direct shipments at prices we guarantee for the duration of projects. Direct shipment enables us to supply the highest quality of materials at the most competitive prices. Understandably, mills offer their lowest prices when they can ship a single product on a rail car or truck. It takes more time to figure out how to load multiple products on a truck, and time is money. What that means for SPI is that we can only save our customers money if their projects are large enough that we can ship 60-70% of the order on straight trucks. Which is why the vast majority of our jobs are multi-family housing, assisted care living, military housing, hospitality, and campus housing. Our business is built on relationships - understanding our customers’ needs and helping them earn contract awards profitably. Over 90% of our orders are repeat business. With sales exceeding a half billion dollars annually, it’s fair to say we’ve earned our customers’ loyalty by outstanding service, quality, and competitive pricing. SPI is a privately held C-Corp with shares held by a clear majority of our employees, including the Board of Directors. Our share ownership creates a culture where all our shareholder/employees embrace the philosophy that our customers’ success is our business model. Position Summary The Business Manager will be the division president’s partner. They will analyze financial statements, review operational reports, and devise tools to refine measurements of success and enhance profitability. Division presidents will focus their efforts on securing business, managing backlogs, and covering open positions. The Business Manager will be responsible for all other aspects of the business. Put simply, Division presidents will be on offense, and Business Managers will keep score and be on defense. This will require Business Managers to lead teams with diverse skill sets to ensure we service our customers’ needs. The Business Manager will be a member of the senior leadership team and will assist in developing and executing long and short-term plans aligned with corporate business goals for profitability and growth. Essential Duties and Responsibilities: Partner with the Division President to execute the strategic plan in conformity with the company’s vision. Support the sales process through thoughtful review of contracts and financial analysis of trading results. Conduct financial reviews including working capital usage, prepare management reports, and evaluate financial and operational results. Prepare short- and long-range budgetary forecasts. Manage risk by thoroughly reviewing and revising contracts and monitoring unbought positions. Evaluate sales and purchasing performance. Monitor inventory management, warehousing, and purchasing. Administer and review inventory processes, programs, and controls to identify problems and suggest resolutions. Develop and monitor proactive reporting and metrics to identify, manage, and mitigate potential risks. Lead and manage the operations teams (trader assistants, project managers, traffic/logistics, etc.). Knowledge, Skills and Abilities: Bachelor’s degree with emphasis in Business, Finance or Accounting. Advanced degree is a plus. 10 years of related experience in Finance or Accounting. CPA not required, but is a plus. Related industry experience in wholesale, distribution, building materials, or construction a plus. Demonstrated leadership in managing staff and major projects or initiatives. Budget development, forecasting, and oversight experience. High energy with a strong work ethic. Critical thinking and problem-solving skills Effective communication skills, verbal and written. Excellent interpersonal skills and a collaborative management style. Ability to create and customize complex analytical documents utilizing Microsoft Office products. Ability to make decisions that significantly impact the company’s credibility, operations, and services. Ability to define issues, collect data, establish facts, and draw valid conclusions. Ability to organize and prioritize workload. Able to travel to customer and company locations. 180one is a retained search firm engaged by Shelter Products to conduct this search. If interested in learning more about the opportunity, please contact Matt Oltmann at matt.oltmann@180one.com / 971.235.6236
05 Feb, 2024
1 80one recently partnered with Seaboard International and is proud to announce the executive placement of a new Controller, Andrew Waples. Forest City Trading Group (FCTG), as an employee-owned organization, is among the largest lumber wholesale distributors in the US with roots going back to the 1960’s. At $7 billion in revenue and growing, we facilitate distribution of products across 6 continents through our network of 13 operating companies and close to 700 employees. Seaboard International is an Operating Company within FCTG that has roots that go back 40 years. They are well established in Nashua, NH as an industry leader in the import and distribution of forest products serving a variety of markets including industrial, construction, and building materials. Congratulations to Seaboard and FCTG and Andrew Waples for a successful hire!
More Posts
Share by: